What Happened to the Bennetts

What Happened to the Bennetts

Now Available in Paperback

★ Short-Listed for the Hammett Prize by the International Association of Crime Writers

★ Amazon Best Book of 2022 – Mystery/Suspense/Thriller of the Year

Kirkus Reviews Best Book of 2022 – Mystery/Thriller of the Year

★ #2 New York Times Bestseller

★ #1 Apple Books Bestseller

USA Today Bestseller

People Book of the Week

★ Library Reads Selection

★ Highly Anticipated Thriller of 2022 by Buzzfeed

★ Goodreads Most Anticipated Spring Book

★ Goodreads Most Anticipated Mystery of 2022

★ Publishers Weekly Top 10 Mystery Thriller of 2022

★ Bookbub Most Anticipated Mystery & Thriller of 2022

★ Top 10 Editors Pick for March by Audiofile Magazine

From number one best-selling author Lisa Scottoline comes a pulse-pounding new novel.

Your family has been attacked, never again to be the same.

Now you have to choose between law…and justice.

Jason Bennett is a suburban dad who owns a court-reporting business, but one night, his life takes a horrific turn. He is driving his family home after his daughter’s field hockey game when a pickup truck begins tailgating them, on a dark stretch of road. Suddenly two men jump from the pickup and pull guns on Jason, demanding the car. A horrific flash of violence changes his life forever.

Later that awful night, Jason and his family receive a visit from the FBI. The agents tell them that the carjackers were members of a dangerous drug-trafficking organization – and now Jason and his family are in their crosshairs. The agents advise the Bennetts to enter the witness protection program right away, and they have no choice but to agree. But WITSEC was designed to protect criminal informants, not law-abiding families. Taken from all they know, trapped in an unfamiliar life, the Bennetts begin to fall apart at the seams. Then Jason learns a shocking truth and realizes that he has to take matters into his own hands.

Sometimes justice is a one-man show.

★ Short-Listed for the Hammett Prize by the International Association of Crime Writers
★ Amazon Best Book of 2022 – Mystery/Suspense/Thriller of the Year
Kirkus Reviews Best Book of 2022 – Mystery/Thriller of the Year
★ #2 New York Times Bestseller
★ #1 Apple Books Bestseller
USA Today Bestseller
People Book of the Week
★ Library Reads Selection
★ Highly Anticipated Thriller of 2022 by Buzzfeed
★ Goodreads Most Anticipated Spring Book
★ Goodreads Most Anticipated Mystery of 2022
★ Publishers Weekly Top 10 Mystery Thriller of 2022
★ Bookbub Most Anticipated Mystery & Thriller of 2022
★ Top 10 Editors Pick for March by Audiofile Magazine

“Scottoline’s writing is full of suspense and plot twists that’ll keep audiences guessing. The intensity of it all is sure to give listeners heart palpitations.”
Library Journal (Starred Review)

“Explosive new complications in the most relentless of all her mysteries. A high-octane thriller…best started early in the morning.”
Kirkus (Starred Review)

“Taut and tense from the first page to the last.”
—Riley Sager, author of Survive the Night

“An emotion-packed thriller that stabs at the core of family, betrayal, and justice. Lisa Scottoline drives the plot at breakneck speed and keeps readers turning the pages. A must read.”
—Robert Dugoni, author of the Tracy Crosswhite Series

“From its opening, heart-grabbing pages, What Happened to the Bennetts is compulsively readable, seamlessly delivering one blazing twist after another.”
—Alafair Burke, author of Find Me

“Heart-wrenching novel…an examination of the profound pain of losing a child morphs into a high-speed, action-packed thriller. Scottoline’s fans will get their money’s worth.”
Publishers Weekly

“Scottoline’s gift for crafting human connections is displayed here in the evocative grief of Veria and the Bennetts, setting this thriller apart from other suburban-hero stories.”

“Twisty, propulsive and exhilarating.”
—Megan Abbott, author of The Turnout

Chapter One

I glanced in my rearview mirror at the pickup truck, which was riding my bumper. I hated tailgaters, especially with my family in the car, but nothing could ruin my good mood. My daughter’s field hockey team had just beat Radnor, and Allison had scored a goal. She was texting in the back seat, one of a generation that makes better use of opposable thumbs than any prior.

My son Ethan turned around next to her, shielding his eyes against the pickup’s headlights. “Dad, what’s up with this guy?”

“God knows. Ignore him.”

“Why don’t you go faster?” Ethan shifted, waking up Moonie, our little white mutt, who started jumping around in the back seat. I love the dog but he has two speeds: Asleep and Annoying.

“Why should I? I’m going the limit.”

“But we can smoke this guy now.”

We had just gotten a new car, a Mercedes E-Class Sedan in a white enamel that gleamed like dental veneers. Ethan said the E stood for his name, but I said Exorbitant. My wife and kids had lobbied for the car, but I felt like a show-off behind the wheel. I missed my old Explorer, which I didn’t need a tie to drive.

“Dad, when I get my license, I’m gonna burn guys like him.”

I heard this once a week. My son counted the days until his learner’s permit, even though he was only thirteen. I said, “No, you’re not. You’re gonna let him pass.”

“We have a right to enjoy the drive.”

“But it’s boring.”

“Not to me. I’m a scenic-route kind of guy.” I moved over to let the pickup pass, since Coldstream Road was a single lane winding uphill through the woods. We were entering the Lagersen Tract, the last parcel of woodland preserved by Chester County, where Nature had to be zoned for her own protection.

I lowered the window and breathed in a lungful of fresh, piney air. Thick trees flanked the road, and scrub brush grew over the guardrails. Crickets and tree frogs croaked a chorus from my childhood. I grew up on a dairy farm in Hershey, home of the famous chocolate manufacturer. I loved living in a company town, where the air smelled of sweet cocoa and corporate largesse. Everyone worked toward the same goal, even if it was capitalism.

“He’s not passing us,” Ethan said, bringing me out of my reverie.

I checked the rearview mirror, squinting against the headlights. Moonie was facing backward, his front paws on the back seat and his ears silhouetted like wispy triangles.

“Come on, Dad. Show ’em who’s boss.”

“That’s well-established,” I said. “Mom.”

Lucinda was in the passenger seat, the curve of her smile illuminated by the phone screen. She was a natural beauty, with gray-blue eyes, a small nose, and dark blond hair gathered into a loose ponytail at the nape of her neck. She had been on Facebook since we’d left the school, posting game photos and comments. Great save by Arielle!!! Lady Patriots rock!!! Woohoo, Emily is MVP!!! My wife never uses fewer than three exclamation marks on social. If you only get one, you’ve done something wrong. Or as my father would say, You’re in the doghouse.

Lucinda looked over. “Jason, speed up, would you?”

“You, too? What’s the hurry?”

“They have homework.”

“On Friday night? Have you met our kids?”

Lucinda smiled, shaking her head. “Whatever, Scenic-Route Kind of Guy.”

“Aw, I feel so seen.”

Lucinda laughed, which made me happy. I love my wife. We met at Bucknell, where she was an art major and I was a work-study jock slinging mac and cheese in the dining hall, wearing a hairnet, no less. She could’ve had her pick, but I made her laugh. Also she loves mac and cheese.

“Dad, listen to this.” Allison looked up, her thumbs still flying. She could text without looking at the keyboard, which she called her superpower. “My friends just voted you Hottest Dad.”

I smiled. “They’re absolutely right. There’s a reason I was Homecoming King.”

“Dude, no. Never say that again.” Allison snorted, texting. “We don’t even have that anymore.”

Lucinda rolled her eyes. “Allison, who came in second?”

I added, “Yeah, what troll came in second?”

Allison kept texting. “Brianna M’s dad.”

I scoffed. “Ron McKinney? Please, no contest. I got the bubble butt.”

Allison smiled. “Stop it!”

“I bet I can twerk, Al. Show you when we get home.”

“Nobody twerks anymore.” Allison snorted again, texting away. “OMG, they’re saying you look like Kyle Chandler.”

“Who’s that?”

“The dad from Friday Night Lights. We watched it together. You remember. Also the dad in Bloodline.”

“What’s that?”

“A show on Netflix.”

“Never saw it.”

“Anyway, you look like him, except he’s way hotter.”

I smiled. “Okay, but can he twerk?”

Allison burst into laughter, and I glanced in the rearview mirror to see her, but the headlights of the pickup truck were too bright. The outline of her head bent over her phone, then I saw the bump of a skinny headband, and the spray of shorter hairs coming from her double ponytail. Those ponytail holders were all over the house, and I fished them from the dog’s mouth on a weekly basis.

Ethan kept twisting around. “Dad, if I were driving, I’d speed up.”

Allison added, “Seriously.”

“Me, too,” Lucinda joined in, still on her phone.

“Okay, I’m convinced.” I pressed the gas pedal, and the Mercedes responded instantly. We accelerated up the hill, hugging the sharp curve to the left.

Oddly the black pickup truck chose that moment to pass us, a dark and dusty blur roaring by with two men in the cab. It crammed us against the guardrail, and I veered to the right, barely fitting on the street.

Suddenly the pickup pulled in front of us and stopped abruptly, blocking our way.

I slammed on the brakes and we shuddered to a stop, inches from the truck. We lurched forward in our seat belts. Lucinda gasped. Moonie started barking.

“It’s okay,” I said, instinctively reversing to put distance between us and the truck. I scanned for an escape route, but there wasn’t one. I couldn’t fit around the truck. I couldn’t reverse down the street because of the blind curve.

Two men emerged from the pickup, illuminated by our headlights. The driver was big, with shredded arms covered by tattooed sleeves. His eyes were slits under a prominent forehead and long, dark hair. His passenger wasn’t as muscular, but had on a similar dark T-shirt and baggy jeans. The driver said something to him as they approached.

I inhaled to calm myself. If it was road rage, I could defuse the situation. I had a year of law school, so I could bullshit with anybody. Otherwise I was six foot three, played middle linebacker in high school, and stayed in decent shape.

Lucinda groaned. “Should I call 911?”

“Not yet.”

“Dad?” Allison sounded nervous.

“What do they want?” Ethan stuck his head between the seats, and Moonie barked, the harsh sound reverberating in the car.

“Don’t worry. Lucinda, lock the doors.”

“Okay, but be careful.”

I climbed out of the car and closed the door behind me, hearing the reassuring thunk of the locks engage. The men reached me, and I straightened. “Gentlemen, is there a-”

“We’re taking the car.” The driver pulled a handgun and aimed it at my face. “Get everybody out.”

“Okay, fine. Relax. Don’t hurt anybody. This is my family.” I turned to the car and spotted Lucinda’s phone glowing through the windshield. She must have been calling 911. The carjackers saw her at the same time.

“Drop it!” The passenger pulled a gun and aimed it at her.

“No, don’t shoot!” I moved in the way, raising my arms. “Honey, everybody, out of the car!”

Lucinda lowered the phone, the screen dropping in a blur of light.

Allison emerged from the back seat, her eyes wide. “Dad, they have guns.”

“It’s okay, honey. Come here.” I put a hand on her shoulder and maneuvered her behind me. Lucinda was coming around the back of the car with Ethan, who held a barking Moonie, dragging his leash. They reached me, and I faced the men.

“Okay, take the car,” I told them, my chest tight.

“Wait.” The passenger eyed Allison, and a leering smile spread across his face. “What’s your name, sweetheart?”

No. My mouth went dry. “Take the car and go.”

Suddenly Moonie leapt from Ethan’s arms and launched himself at the men. They jumped back, off-balance. The driver fired an earsplitting blast, just missing Moonie.

My ears rang. I whirled around.

Allison had been struck. Blood spurted from her neck in a gruesome fan. She was reeling.

No! I rushed to her just as she collapsed in my arms. I eased her down to the street. Her mouth gaped open. Her throat emitted gulping sounds. Blood poured from her neck. My hand flew there to stop the flow. The blood felt hideously wet and warm.

Allison’s lips were moving. She was trying to talk, to breathe.

“Honey, you’ve been hit,” I told her. “Stay calm.” I tore off my shirt, breaking the buttons. I bunched it up and pressed it against her neck. I couldn’t see the wound. It scared me to death. “Lucinda, call 911.”

“My phone’s in the car!” Lucinda grabbed Allison’s hand, beginning to sob.

Suddenly the gun fired again behind us, another earsplitting blast.

We crouched in terror. Lucinda screamed. I didn’t know who had been shot. I looked around wildly, shocked to find that one carjacker had shot the other. The driver stood over the passenger, who lay motionless on the street, blood pooling under his head. The driver dropped the gun and ran to the pickup. I spotted his license plate before he sped off. A sudden brightness told me another car was coming up Coldstream.

“Dad, there’s Allison’s phone!” Ethan thrust it at me. My bloody fingers smeared the screen, which came to life with a photo of Moonie in sunglasses.

I thumbed to the phone function and pressed 911. The call connected. I held the phone to my ear to hear over the dog’s barking.

The 911 dispatcher asked, “What is your emergency?”

“My daughter’s been shot in the neck. Two men tried to carjack us on Coldstream Road near the turnpike overpass.” I struggled to think through my fear. Allison was making gulping sounds. She was losing blood fast, drenching my shirt. My hands were slick with my daughter’s lifeblood, slipping warm through my fingers.

“Sir, is she awake and responsive?”

“Yes, send an ambulance! Hurry!”

“Apply direct pressure to the wound. Use a compress-”

“I am, please send-”

“An ambulance is on the way.”

“Please! Hurry!”

Allison’s eyelids fluttered. She coughed. Pinkish bubbles frothed at the corners of her mouth. “Daddy?”

My heart lurched. She hadn’t called me that since she was little.

I told her what I wanted to believe: “You’re going to be okay.”

Chapter Two

The waiting room of the emergency department was harshly bright, and the mint-green walls were lined with idealized landscapes of foxhunts. Green-padded chairs had been arranged in two rectangles, forming rooms without walls. The front section held a handful of people, but we had the back to ourselves. Wrinkled magazines lay on end tables, ignored in favor of phones. There was a kids’ playroom behind a plexiglass wall next to vending machines.

I had been in this waiting room so many times over the years, for so many reasons. Allison’s broken arm. Ethan’s random falls. Once, a moth flew into Lucinda’s ear. Every parent knows the local emergency room, but not like this. Never before had I seen anyone look like us, right now.

The three of us huddled together, shocked and stricken. Allison had been taken to surgery. My undershirt was stiffening with drying blood, and Lucinda had spatters on her Lady Patriots sweatshirt and bloody patches on her jeans. She had stopped crying and rested her head on my right shoulder. Ethan’s T-shirt was flecked with blood, though the fabric was black and it didn’t show except for the white N in Nike. He slumped on my left, and I had an arm around each of them.

“She’ll be okay, right?” Lucinda asked, hushed.

“Yes,” I answered, but I was scared out of my mind. “How was she in the ambulance?”

“Okay. She didn’t panic. You know her.”

“Yes.” I nodded. Allison had a high pain threshold. At lacrosse camp, she broke her arm in the morning and didn’t tell her coach until lunch.

“The EMT was in the back, I had to sit in the front. He was nice. He talked to her. He called in her vital signs.”

“How were they?”

“Her blood pressure was low.” Lucinda started wringing her hands. I remembered her doing that when her sister Caitlin was dying of breast cancer, five years ago. I hugged her closer.

An older couple shuffled in together and took a seat in our section, glancing around. The husband had a walker with new tennis balls on the bottom, and he walked ahead with concentration. His wife noticed us, then plastered her gaze to the TV, showing the news on closed-captioning.

Lucinda wiped her nose with a balled-up Kleenex. “Jason, do you know what she said to me in the ambulance? She told me not to worry.”

Tears stung my eyes. “What a kid.”

“I know.” Lucinda sniffled. “I wonder how long the surgery will be.”

“They have to repair the vein. I think it was a vein, not an artery.”

“How do you know?”

“If it were an artery, like the carotid, the blood would have pulsed out.” I hoped I was right. Any medical information I had was from malpractice depositions, of which I’d done hundreds. I was a court reporter, which made me a font of information about completely random subjects. It wasn’t always a good thing.

“We were supposed to look for a homecoming dress tomorrow. She found one she liked at the mall. She saw it with Courtney.”

I remembered. Allison had shown me a picture on her phone. The dress was nice, white with skinny straps. She would have looked great in it. She had the wiry, lean build of an athlete. She worried it would make her butt look flat.

Allison, your butt isn’t flat.

Dad, you don’t know. You just love me.

I had so many nicknames for her. Al, Alsford, The Duchess of Alfordshire, and The Alimentary Canal because she ate like a horse. She called me Dad or Dude. I was an involved father, according to my wife. I was present in my children’s lives. I sold raffle tickets and bought gigantic candy bars that I gave out at work. I taught both kids to pitch and saw that Allison was the better athlete.

Lucinda sniffled again. “I assume they’ll keep her a few days, don’t you?”


“I suppose I could pick it up for her.”

“Pick what up?”

Ethan looked over, his wet eyes glistening. “The dress, Dad.”

“Right.” I was too upset to think, it just didn’t show. I couldn’t follow the conversation. My wife talked more when she was upset,but I talked less. I was lost in my own thoughts. I was lost.

Lucinda wiped her nose. “I hope she can still go to homecoming.She’s so excited. I think she really likes Troy.”

“I know.” Troy was Allison’s boyfriend of two months, already lasting longer than her last boyfriend. I liked Troy because he wasas smart as she was, a true scholar athlete. He was on the quiet side, but I learned from having Ethan that there’s more to introverts than meets the eye. My son had a circle of friends, butneeded time to himself.

“I got her a hair appointment the same day as the dance.They all want to get in the morning of, but they don’t want to miss the game. It was impossible, but I got her in.” Lucinda’s voice carried an unmistakable note of mom pride.

  1. In the novel’s early chapters, Jason reflects a lot on his old life and lost home. What do you think this novel is trying to say about the suburbs and their importance to the American family?
  2. Several characters in the novel cite their everyday “superpowers.” Jason’s lipreading, or Allison’s texting without looking at the keyboard, for example. How else do you think this novel explores the heroism of everyday people?
  3. How do you think the events of the novel would have unfolded differently if Allison had survived the attack?
  4. If the FBI advised your family to join a WITSEC program, would you go? Why?
  5. If you were to join a WITSEC program, who would you most regret not being able to tell? Why?
  6. If you had to leave your home suddenly, which objects would be the most poignant for you to leave behind, and why?
  7. Discuss the different ways in which Jason, Lucinda, and Ethan experience their grief. Do you think that these differences reflect the underlying cracks in Jason and Lucinda’s marriage?
  8. What was your favorite quote or passage, and why?
  9. The novel has many twists and turns. Did you guess any of them ahead of time? If so, at which point, and why?
  10. The book features many different parent-child relationships. Jason and his father, Lucinda and her mother, Allison and Jason, Allison and Lucinda, Junior and Big George. Did one or several relationships strike you as healthier or happier than the others, and why?
  11. Do you think Jason’s motivation to take action into his own hands went beyond the desire to protect his family from Milo? What else do you think might have affected his decisions?
  12. What do you think this novel is trying to say about various forms of justice? Legal, emotional, and interpersonal?
  13. What do you imagine will happen to the Bennetts after the novel’s end? How do you see Jason, Lucinda, and Ethan changing in the wake of these incidents?
  14. Scottoline believes that novels build empathy, nurture the self, and connect us by the truths they contain. Did this novel change the way you think about family, justice, or the American dream?

People Magazine Book of the Week Feature